3 Best Italian Restaurants in Orangeville, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Orangeville, ON. All of our italian restaurants actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

BLUEBIRD CAFE & GRILL

100 Broadway,
Orangeville, ON L9W 1J9 Directions

Since 2019

Specialities:

✓Porcini Cannelloni ✓Seafood Cannelloni ✓Fettuccine Chicken Primavera ✓Baked Lasagna ✓Smoky Farfalle ✓Penne Palermo ✓Angel Hair Bella ✓Pasqualotti Fufferelli ✓Hot Italian Sausage Penne ✓Grilled Seafood Fettuccine ✓Linguine Gambero ✓Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich ✓California Club Wrap ✓Crepes Cordon Bleu ✓Veal Cutlet Sandwich ✓Grilled Sirloin Sandwich ✓Vegetable Plate ✓Italian Minestrone ✓French Onion Soup ✓House Mixed Greens ✓Caesar Alla Bluebird ✓Greek Salad ✓Spinach Alla Blue Cheese ✓Bluebird Chop Salad

"Bluebird Cafe & Grill is a modern, contemporary eatery featuring pasta, Italian entrees, steak and wood-fired pizzas. Their team uses only the finest, freshest ingredients. All of their products are prepared in-house and are always fresh to order. Their chefs are highly creative, passionate professionals and provide high-quality menus. The restaurant has many menus and offers many soups, salads, entrees, and grill dishes. Entrees are served with stir-fried vegetables and mini-roasted potatoes. Gluten-free pasta dishes are available on request. They pride themselves on offering a culinary and hospitality experience. Michelle and Rick Arsenault are the owners of the restaurant. Their menu is prepared with care, featuring Italian-inspired specialties, their famous wood-fired pizza, Certified Angus beef, and a dedication to using only the freshest, finest-quality ingredients. Gift cards are also available at the restaurant.

2026 Highlights: They originally opened in 1982 as a natural food store and vegetarian eatery, taking their name from the local Eastern Bluebird repopulation initiative in Dufferin County."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pasta
Porcini Cannelloni $20
Seafood Cannelloni $23
Fettuccine Chicken Primavera $23
Baked Lasagna $24
Smoky Farfalle $23
Penne Palermo $22
Angel Hair Bella $22
Pasqualotti Fufferelli $23
Hot Italian Sausage Penne $23
Grilled Seafood Fettuccine $30
Linguine Gambero $28
Wood Fired Pizza
Santa Margherita $18
Napoli $20
Florence $21
Venice $20
Rimini $21
Imola $20
Milan $21
Ferraro $21
Catanzaro $21
Sandwiches & Fav'S
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich $18
California Club Wrap $17
Crepes Cordon Bleu $17
Veal Cutlet Sandwich $19
Grilled Sirloin Sandwich $20
Vegetable Plate $17
Entrées
Vitello Pugliese $29
6 Oz Sirloin $27
Steelhead Trout Fillet $30

Contact:

(519) 941-3101 (519) 941-5246

Tue-Sat: 11:30am - 9pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

5+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

ANGELS DINER ORANGEVILLE

33 Broadway,
Orangeville, ON L9W 1J7 Directions

Since 1996

Specialities:

✓Penne and Meat Sauce ✓Spaghetti and Meat Sauce ✓Penne Alfredo ✓Fettuccine Alfredo ✓Baked Three Cheese Penne ✓Chicken Parmesan ✓Spaghetti or Penne With Meat Sauce ✓Spaghetti and Alfredo ✓Hot Beef ✓Hot Chicken ✓Hamburger Steak ✓Salmon Filet ✓Chicken Filet ✓NY Steak (6oz) ✓Chicken or Pork Souvlaki Platter ✓Baby Beef Liver ✓Fish and Chips ✓Seniors Deluxe ✓Chicken Salad Sandwich ✓Veggie Omelette ✓Spinach ✓Feta and Tomato Omelette ✓Angels Omelette ✓Western Omelette ✓Cheese Omelette ✓Ham or Cheese Omelette ✓All Day Breakfast

"Angels Diner Orangeville restaurant offers breakfast, lunch and dinner meals with mouthwatering dishes. The knowledgeable and friendly staff provides excellent service. Customers can enjoy their award-winning fall-off-the-bone baby back ribs, famous chicken tenders, fresh salads, club sandwiches, pasta, fish, steaks, burgers, and more at moderate prices. Kid's menu and seniors' menu options are available. They aim to provide quality food served in an excellent family atmosphere. Angels Diner Orangeville also offers dessert menus. The restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy your delicious dishes.

2026 Highlights: They are known for their fresh ingredients, generous portions, fabulous desserts, and a specialized menu that includes Montreal smoked meat, souvlaki, and ribs."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

PASTA:
Spaghetti With Meat Sauce $12.99
Penne With Rose Sauce $12.99
Fettuccine Alfredo $12.99
Add Chicken $5.99
MAINS:
Liver & Onions $14.99
Hot Hamburger $14.99
Hot Chicken $14.99
Fish & Chips (1 Pc) $11.99
Fish & Chips (2 Pc) $15.99
Chicken Fingers (6) With Fries $14.99
Chicken Souvlaki Dinner $16.99
Pork Souvlaki Dinner $16.99
Steak Dinner $21.99
BURGERS:
Hamburger: $13.99
Cheeseburger: $14.49
Big Bopper: $16.99
Angel's Burger: $17.99
Veggie Burger: $15.99
Angry Burger: $16.99
Santa Fe Burger: $16.99
Fats Domino: $16.99
Jimmy Dean: $15.99
Lumberjack Burger: $17.99
Premium Ground Chuck: $16.99
BBQ Rib Combos: $26.99
Ribs & Tenders: $26.99
Santa Fe Chicken: $21.99
Ribs & Chicken: $26.99
Half Rack Baby Back Ribs: $18.99
Amarillo Chicken: $20.99

Contact:

(519) 943-0588

Wed-Sat: 8am - 8pm
Mon & Tue: 8am - 3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

THE CRAFT PIZZA BAR & ITALIAN KITCHEN

111 Broadway,
Orangeville, ON L9W 1K2 Directions

Since 2022

Specialities:

✓Chicken Marsala ✓Bistecca ✓Chicken Piccata ✓Fettine ✓Risotto ✓Pasta Fatta In Casa ✓Bucatini Sporca ✓Bucatini All' Amatriciana Norma ✓Pappardelle Ricce Bolognese ✓Tonnarelli Alla Gricia ✓Tagliatelle Tartufo E Gorgonzola ✓Chitarra E Polpette ✓Gnocchi Bolognese ✓Chitarra Puttanesca ✓Tonnarelli Arrabbiata ✓Tagliatelle Pescatore ✓Tortellini Crema Di Peperoni Rossi ✓Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina ✓Shrimp Fra Diavolo ✓Tortellini Con Crema ✓Gorg and Shrooms ✓New York Cheese ✓Properoni ✓Vodka Roni ✓Carne ✓Pollo Pazzo ✓Sausage and Roni ✓Canadese ✓Deluxe ✓Blasph

"The Craft Pizza Bar & Italian Kitchen is an Authentic Italian Restaurant founded by Chef and Maestro Pizzaiolo Paul Fuda and his partner, Kelly. With over 35 years of culinary experience, Chef Paul Fuda skillfully crafts each dish, flavor-packed Italian cuisine. They have been committed to using only the freshest ingredients and time-honored cooking methods to offer a dining experience rooted in authenticity, passion, and the rich traditions of Italian cooking. Dine in, takeout, and catering options are also available at the restaurant.

2026 Highlights: They combine traditional Italian cooking methods with fresh ingredients and modern creativity to serve comforting, authentic flavors."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pasta:
Pasta Pomodoro $22
Pasta Gorgonzola E Funghi $24
Tortellini Crema Di Peperoni Rossi $27
Pasta Shrimp Fra Diavolo $29
Pasta Genovese $26
Pasta Bolognese $24
Gnocchi Gorgonzola E Funghi $27
Spaghetti Chitarra Puttanesca $25
Spaghetti Bolognese $24
Tortellini Con Crema $25
18" Pizzas:
18" Build Your Own Pizza $29
18" The Craft $36
18" Carne $36
18" Gorg & Shrooms $35
18" Deluxe $35
18" Canadese $34
18" New York Cheese $28
18" Margherita-Ish $29
18" Properoni $33
18" Vodka Roni $34
18" Diavola $34
18" Buffalo Chicken $35
18" Sausage & Roni $34
18" Vodka Roni Piccante $34
18" Pollo Pazzo $36
18" Quattro Formaggio $33
18" Vedura $33
18" Blasphemy $34
11" Pizzas
Build Your Own Personal $19
11" Margherita $20
11" Vodka Roni Piccante $23

Contact:

(519) 943-1313

Tue-Thu: 11:30am - 8pm
Fri & Sat: 11:30am - 9pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.