3 Best Insurance Brokers in Orangeville, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Insurance Agency in Orangeville, ON. All of our insurance brokers actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

Absolute Insurance Brokers - Orangeville, ON Insurance Brokers - Insurance Team Image
Absolute Insurance Brokers - Orangeville, ON Insurance Brokers - Office Exterior Image
Absolute Insurance Brokers - Orangeville, ON Insurance Brokers - Insurance Agency Image
9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

ABSOLUTE INSURANCE BROKERS

71 Fifth Avenue,
Orangeville, ON L9W 1G3

Since 2007

Specialty:

✓Personal ✓Car Insurance ✓Telematics / Usage Based Insurance ✓High Risk Auto Insurance ✓Young Driver Auto Insurance ✓Home Insurance ✓Tenant Insurance ✓Financial Life and Wealth Services ✓Life Insurance ✓Travel Insurance ✓Professional Liability Insurance ✓Commercial Vehicle Insurance ✓Fleet and Commercial Automobile Telematics ✓Contractor Insurance ✓Metal Manufacturing ✓Cyber Liability Insurance and Building Owner Insurance

"Absolute Insurance Brokers gives you the advice to make an educated decision when purchasing insurance for your cars, houses, business, work vehicles, farm operations and life insurance. Lyndon Lichty and Ryan Tupper started Absolute Insurance Brokers in 2007. Absolute Insurance Brokers provides specialized insurance for farriers and dairy farms in Orangeville and surrounding areas. They have the expertise to find the coverage your business requires to provide peace of mind. Their insurance brokers are encouraged to grow in their current roles and learn about the new insurance industry. The firm provides a full range of insurance options and coverage. They have expanded their area of operation to include the surrounding areas, such as Guelph, Newmarket, Alliston, Barrie, Tottenham, Angus, and Elora. You can contact them to get a quote. Their team is continually training, learning and refining their customer service skills to offer you world-class service.

2026 Highlights: Absolute Insurance Brokers offers several discounts, including Multi-Line, Winter Tire, Multi-Car, Aftermarket Alarm, GPS Tracking, My Home My Auto, My Driving, Good Student, Graduated License, Driver Training, and Student Away at School discounts."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #1000193054

Contact:

(519) 941-2266 (877) 941-2266

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

BILLYARD INSURANCE GROUP ORANGEVILLE

28 Mill Street, Unit 113,
Orangeville, ON L9W 2M3 Directions

Specialty:

✓Car ✓RV/motorhome ✓Life Insurance ✓Critical Illness ✓Personal Health ✓Pet ✓Group Benefits ✓Classic Car ✓Boat ✓Motorcycle ✓Home ✓Condo ✓Tenants ✓Rental Property ✓Cottage ✓Commercial Liability ✓Professional Liability ✓Small Business ✓Commercial Property and Auto ✓Travel Insurance ✓Frequent Traveller ✓Students and Seniors Insurance and Visitors to Canada Insurance

"Billyard Insurance Group Orangeville offers a variety of products, including home, auto, commercial, farm, life, and travel insurance. Mike Yestal is the firm's managing partner. The firm has access to a network of over 30 trusted insurance providers. They have the best insurance brokers to find you the best price and coverage while providing outstanding and personal customer service. Their mission is to build a nationally acknowledged insurance brand created to empower brokers and lead the digital insurance revolution. The team of licensed Orangeville insurance brokers will work with you every step of the way. They will use their variety of trusted insurance partners to ensure you receive the best rates available and the best coverage. Billyard Insurance Group provides services to clients in Ontario, Alberta, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick.

2026 Highlights: Billyard Insurance Group provides 24/7 digital access to documents and services, including claims, billing changes, pink slips, vehicle changes, address changes, adding drivers, and payments."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Insurance Brokers - Winner by Canadian Choice Award in 2026

Contact:

(519) 943-1919 (866) 498-4935

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

NICOL INSURANCE INC.

695 Riddell Road, Unit 3,
Orangeville, ON L9W 7S4

Since 1950

Specialty:

✓Home ✓Auto ✓High Value Homes ✓Condominiums ✓Cottage/Seasonal Homes ✓Hobby Farms ✓Boat/Yachts ✓Tenant ✓Personal Umbrella Liability ✓Recreational Vehicles ✓Motorcycles ✓Antique or Classic Cars ✓Commercial Property ✓Business Interruption ✓Commercial General Liability ✓Commercial Excess and Umbrella Liability ✓Cyber Insurance ✓Directors and Officers Liability ✓Professional Liability/Errors and Omissions ✓Environmental (Pollution) Insurance ✓Bonding/Surety and Special Events Insurance

"Nicol Insurance Inc. is a licensed insurance broker with the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO). They are a professional organization dedicated to providing insurance solutions at competitive pricing. Their experienced brokers can help you determine the right kind of coverage you need to protect your unique lifestyle. The vision of Nicol Insurance is to be an industry leader as both a community and client-centric business. They will support those who help them succeed and work towards creating stability and trust with every decision they make. Their brokers use their professional knowledge and experience to carefully shop the market and present you with the best insurance coverage. One of their representatives is always there to help in the event of a claim. The firm also serves in Mississauga, Woodstock, Kincardine, Owen Sound, Port Elgin, Windsor and Bruce Peninsula. They have been helping clients identify and provide them with the best value in personal and commercial insurance for 75 years.

2026 Highlights: Nicol Insurance Inc. provides specialized insurance coverage for local farms and hobby farms."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Contact:

(519) 941-6001 (800) 376-5350

Mon-Fri: 9am - 4pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.