3 Best Italian Restaurants in Orillia, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Orillia, ON. All of our italian restaurants actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

Theo’s Eatery - Orillia, ON Italian Restaurants - Food Image
Theo’s Eatery - Orillia, ON Italian Restaurants - Restaurant Exterior Image
Theo’s Eatery - Orillia, ON Italian Restaurants - collage image(highlights)
5+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

THEO’S EATERY

214 Memorial Avenue,
Orillia, ON L3V 5X6 Directions

Since 1993

Specialities:

✓Bacon and Tomato Melt ✓California Melt ✓Veggie Mini Pizza ✓BBQ Mini Pizza ✓Theo’s Combination Mini ✓Spaghetti ✓Roasted Pepper Fusilli ✓Fusilli Pesto ✓Theo’s Alfredo ✓Penne California ✓Chicken Tetrazzini ✓Lasagna ✓Penne ✓Vegetarian Lasagna ✓Alfredo Al Forno ✓Chicken and Cheese Tortellini ✓Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich ✓Steak Sandwich ✓Grilled Chicken Sandwich ✓Roasted Veggie Wrap ✓Chicken Caesar Wrap ✓Pork Souvlaki Wrap ✓Theo’s Club ✓Tuscan Grilled Cheese

"Theo’s Eatery is a family-owned and operated restaurant that offers a casual environment for dining. The restaurant has over 50 staff members who are always ready to serve customers. Their wide range of menu offers a wide selection of Starters, Soups, Salads, Casual Classics, Pasta, oven-baked pasta and desserts. Customers can customize their pizza dish with topping choices. Theo’s Eatery offers Mediterranean fare like Souvlaki, Lamb Chops, Vegetarian Classic, and Tuscan Pizza. The restaurant accepts reservations, and gift cards are available.Theo’s Eatery is proud to offer a fully licensed dining room as well as take-out and delivery.

2026 Highlights: They are highly recommended for their friendly staff and delicious menu highlights like their signature baked lasagna and Caesar salad."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #1000758817

Menu:

Pasta
Chicken Tetrazzini $19.39
Penne California $19.39
House Special $18.19
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce $14.19
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce With Mushrooms $16.79
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce With Meatballs $16.79
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce With Mushrooms & Meatballs $17.89
Fusilli Pesto $17.29
Fusilli Pesto With Chicken $20.39
Fusilli Pesto With Shrimp $20.39
Roasted Pepper Fusilli $16.79
Roasted Pepper Fusilli With Chicken $19.89
Roasted Pepper Fusilli With Sausage $19.89
Theo'S Alfredo $16.29
Theo'S Alfredo With Chicken $19.39
Theo'S Alfredo With Shrimp $19.39
Oven Baked Pasta
Alfredo Al Forno $19.19
Chicken & Cheese Tortellini $19.19
Baked Spaghetti $16.29
Baked Spaghetti With Mushrooms $18.39
Baked Spaghetti With Meatballs $18.39
Baked Spaghetti With Mushrooms & Meatballs $20.39
Lasagna $16.29

Contact:

(705) 329-4444

Tue-Fri: 11am - 9pm
Sat: 4pm - 9pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

EAST SIDE MARIO'S ORILLIA

315 Memorial Avenue,
Orillia, ON L3V 5Y1 Directions

Since 1987

Specialities:

✓Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini ✓Double-bacon Carbonara ✓Linguine Chicken Amatriciana ✓Scallop Carbonara ✓Cheese Cappelletti ✓Gigantico Three Cheese Ravioli ✓Spaghetti Primavera with Goat Cheese ✓12 Layer Lasagna ✓Sausage and Peppers Penne ✓Shrimp Alfredo ✓Seafood Linguine ✓Roasted Garlic Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken ✓Mario's Spaghetti and Meatballs ✓Fettuccine Alfredo ✓Cheesy Baked Penne with Rosé ✓Spaghetti Bolognese ✓Mario's Chicken Parmigiana ✓Triple Threat Parmigiana ✓Veal Parmigiana ✓Mario's Mangia Sampler

"East Side Mario's Orillia has a family-friendly, fun and casual environment in which to enjoy dining. They have an extensive range of menu selections, including pasta, starters, parmigiana, desserts, sandwiches, pizza, and more. All their dishes are served in generous portions at affordable prices. The staff at the Orillia location are friendly and provide excellent customer service. The restaurant is the perfect place to celebrate your special occasions with family and friends. Delivery and dine-in options are available at East Side Mario's. Whether you're looking for a dine-in experience for lunch and dinner or prefer the convenience of takeout or delivery, they cater to every preference.

2026 Highlights: They also feature unique daily promotions like All-You-Can-Eat Pasta Mondays, Kids Eat Free Tuesdays, and a special Amore for Two dinner deal every Thursday."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pasta
Cheese Cappelletti $23.29
Roasted Garlic Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken $23.79
Mario's Spaghetti & Meatballs $22.99
Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini $23.49
Double-Bacon Carbonara $23.99
Sausage & Peppers Penne $22.99
Linguine Chicken Amatriciana $23.89
Shrimp Alfredo $24.89
Spaghetti Primavera With Goat Cheese $22.99
Gigantico Three Cheese Ravioli $24.99
Homemade Meat Lasagna $24.29
Build Your Own Pasta $21.99
Shrimp & Salmon Spaghetti $26.49
Crispy Chicken Bacon Rosé $24.99
Creamy Garlic Steak Fettuccine $26.99
Fettuccine Alfredo $19.99
Cheesy Baked Penne With Rosé $19.99
Spaghetti Bolognese $19.99
Pizza
Four Meat Pizza $16.99
The Ultimate Canadian Pizza $16.99
Hawaiian Heat Pizza $16.99
Balsamic Pesto Pizza $16.99
Pepperoni Calzone $17.99
The Ultimate Canadian Calzone $17.99

Discount:

Get Free Appetizer Just by Signing Up

Contact:

(705) 329-2800

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

TRE SORELLE

37 Mississauga Street West,
Orillia, ON L3V 3A5 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

✓Cheese Manicotti ✓Pasta and Meatballs ✓Chicken Parmigiana ✓Veal Parmigiana ✓Spaghetti Carbonara Pasta ✓Lasagna ✓Pesto Pasta ✓Gluten-Free Pasta with Veggies ✓Fresh Pasta ✓Caprese Panini ✓Meatball Panini ✓Chicken Panini ✓Veal Panini ✓Veggie Panini ✓Caesar Salad ✓Goat Cheese Salad ✓Cannoli and Tiramisu

"Tre Sorelle restaurant is a family-friendly atmosphere for their customers. Their staff are very professional and support all the customers' needs. They serve only mouthwatering homemade Italian menus at reasonable prices. They have a wide range of menus using fresh source ingredients. Tre Sorelle offers an excellent selection of takeout items stored in the freezer, allowing you to enjoy their delectable cuisine in the comfort of your own home. The restaurant is the perfect spot for all the special occasions and lunch and dinner nights with family and friends. They also have great take-out items in the freezer for replicating the food at home.

2026 Highlights: They function as a family-run shop offering both fresh pasta café dining and a convenience freezer stock of ready-made take-home meals."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Panini
Veal or Chicken $17.00
Meatball $17.00
Veggie $17.00
Caprese $17.00
Pasta
Lasagna $15.00
Pesto Pasta $20.00
Parmigiana $20.00

Contact:

(705) 325-8507

Wed-Sat: 10am - 4pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.