ThreeBestRated.ca
BEST RATED WHITCHURCH-STOUFFVILLE, ON ITALIAN RESTAURANTS

3 Best Italian Restaurants in Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON. All of our italian restaurants actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

Stouffville italian restaurant East Side Mario's Stouffville
Stouffville italian restaurant East Side Mario's Stouffville
Stouffville italian restaurant East Side Mario's Stouffville
Stouffville italian restaurant East Side Mario's Stouffville video
5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

EAST SIDE MARIO'S STOUFFVILLE

(5.0 Score)
5769 Main Street,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 4R2 Directions

Since 1987

Specialty:

✓ Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini ✓ Double-Bacon Carbonara ✓ Linguine Chicken Amatriciana ✓ Cheese Cappelletti ✓ Lasagna ✓ Gigantic Three Cheese Ravioli ✓ Spaghetti Primavera with Goat Cheese ✓ Sausage and Peppers Penne ✓ Jumbo Shrimp Alfredo ✓ Seafood Linguine ✓ Roasted Garlic Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken ✓ Mario's Spaghetti and Meatballs ✓ Build Your Own Pasta ✓ Scallop Carbonara

“East Side Mario's Stouffville is a fine dining restaurant chain Italian restaurant that proudly serves the community with the best dining experience. Their team of staff use only high-quality ingredients for their dishes. The restaurant is the perfect place to dine in on special occasions like birthdays, anniversaries, business meetings, and more. They have a wide range of menus, are entrees, pasta, sandwiches, parmigiana, pizza, soups, salads, starters, and desserts at affordable prices. Place your order online and enjoy the Italian experience at home. East Side Mario's Stouffville offers gift cards in various price ranges. On Wednesdays, join them in their dining rooms and enjoy All-You-Can-Eat pasta with soup & salads.

2025 Update: The restaurant also offers Wifi, takeout, delivery, patio, curbside pick-up, and bar. They provide Buy One, Take One Home Free on every Wednesday. Sign up on their website and receive a free starter on your next online order. They provide gift cards.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #281195693

Price:

PASTA
Build Your Own Pasta $25.53
Double-Bacon Carbonara $27.19
Cheese Cappelletti $26.72
Gigantico Three Cheese Ravioli $28.50
Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini $27.19
Mario's Spaghetti & Meatballs $26.12
Sausage & Peppers Penne $26.12
Linguine Chicken Amatriciana $27.19
Shrimp Alfredo $28.50
Seafood Linguine $29.69
Spaghetti Primavera with Goat Cheese $26.12
12 Layer Lasagna $28.50
Fettuccine Alfredo $23.75
Cheesy Baked Penne with Rosé $23.75
Spaghetti Bolognese $23.75
PIZZA 'N' CALZONES
Ultimate Canadian Calzone $21.37
14'' Loaded Pepperoni $29.69
Pepperoni Calzone $21.37
14'' Hawaiian Heat $29.69
14'' Four Meat $29.69
10'' Ultimate Canadian Pizza $20.18
14'' Ultimate Canadian Pizza $29.69
10'' Loaded Pepperoni $20.18
10'' Balsamic Pesto Pizza $20.18
10'' Hawaiian Heat $20.18
10'' Four Meat $20.18

Contact:

(365) 521-2002

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Stouffville italian restaurant Pastaggio Italian Eatery
Stouffville italian restaurant Pastaggio Italian Eatery
Stouffville italian restaurant Pastaggio Italian Eatery
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PASTAGGIO ITALIAN EATERY

(4.8 Score)
6211 Main Street,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 4J3 Directions

Specialty:

✓ Lasagna ✓ Cappelletti ✓ Gnocchi ✓ Spaghetti with Meatballs ✓ Spaghetti Aglio e Olio ✓ Strozzapreti with Rapini and Sausage ✓ Fettuccine Alfredo ✓ Pasta alla Vodka ✓ Penne Arrabbiata ✓ Spaghetti con Gamberi e Calamari ✓ Pasta with Meat Sauce ✓ Pasta Primavera ✓ Fusilli Salmone ✓ Chicken Penne Pesto ✓ Veal ✓ Chicken Cutlet ✓ Meatball ✓ Italian Sausage ✓ Ravioli ✓ Pappardelle with Spicy Jumbo Shrimp

“Pastaggio Italian Eatery is an authentic Italian restaurant that provides the freshest and finest ingredients used to prepare their house specialties, including their Polo Parigina, Agnello alla Grilla, and unique pasta dishes, such as their Stozzapreti with Rapini and Sausage or Pasta alla Vodka. They strive to provide customers with the best quality food in a cozy environment. You will experience the flavourful food prepared by their professional staff. The restaurant also offers catering and hall rental services. Visit and dine with them to experience the best Italian cuisine in town.

2025 Update: They offer dine-in, take out, catering, special events and upstairs hall rental. Their chefs use only the premium tomatoes and the best herbs and spices when preparing their sauces.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review
Reader's Choice Best Italian Restaurant in 2009

Price:

PASTA
Lasagna $26
Ravioli $28
Gnocchi $25
Spaghetti with Meatballs $25
Spaghetti Aglio e Olio $18
Strozzapreti with Rapini and Sausage $26
Fettuccine Alfredo $25
Pasta alla Vodka $25
Penne Arrabbiata $20
Spaghetti con Gamberi e Calamari $27
Pasta with Meat Sauce $25
Pappardelle with Spicy Jumbo Shrimp $29
Pasta Primavera $22
Fusilli Salmone $25
Chicken Penne Pesto $26
ENTRÉES
Veal Parmigiana $32
Chicken Parmigiana $32
Pollo Parigina $37
Veal Chop (12 oz) $49
Steak (14 oz prime rib) $49
Add peppercorn sauce $5
APPETIZERS / STARTERS
Calamari alla Griglia $22
Caprese Salad $17
Bocconcini Balls $19
Pastaggio Baskets $15
Garlic Bread $9
Garlic Bread w/ cheese $11
Prosciutto con Arugula e Formaggio $19
Carpaccio $23
Arancini $19
Gambari alla Griglia $23
Antipasto Platter small $40
Antipasto Platter large $55

Contact:

(905) 642-5617

Thu: 4pm - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 9:30 pm
Sun-Wed: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Stouffville italian restaurant Il Postino
Stouffville italian restaurant Il Postino
Stouffville italian restaurant Il Postino
Stouffville italian restaurant Il Postino video
7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

IL POSTINO

(4.7 Score)
186 Main Street, Unionville,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L3R 2G9 Directions

Since 2005

Specialty:

✓ Mozzarella Caprese ✓ Cavolo Salad ✓ Arancini ✓ Grilled Branzino ✓ Spicy Prawn Linguine ✓ Rigatoni Vodka ✓ Spaghetti Cacio e Peppe ✓ Fettuccine Limone ✓ Tagliatelle Ragu ✓ Orecchiette Sausage and Rapini ✓ Seafood Linguine ✓ Chicken Caesar ✓ Margherita Pizza ✓ Diavola Pizza ✓ Pappardelle Funghi ✓ Chicken Parmesan ✓ Branzino ✓ Mushroom and Truffle Pizza ✓ Salsiccia Pizza ✓ Parma Pizza ✓ Steak Frites ✓ Burrata Caprese ✓ Calamari Fritti ✓ Caesar Salad ✓ Carpaccio

“Il Postino offers high-quality Italian fare, including house-made pasta. This restaurant is located 20 minutes from the downtown of Stouffville. The restaurant has a welcoming environment with a house-front patio. The secret success of this restaurant is outstanding service, exceptional service, and authentic food. Their team of staff use only good quality ingredients to make their delicious dishes. They have a daily special and an extensive wine list to enjoy. Il Postino's goal is to give authentic dishes to their customers. Their food is very flavorful, and the prices are reasonable. Guests can also enjoy their dining on a beautiful outdoor patio area.

2025 Update: The restaurant has received the Consumer Choice Award. They provide a gift card that never expires.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

PASTA
Fettuccine Limone $25
Tagliatelle Ragu $26
Orecchiette Sausage & Rapini $27
Rigatoni Vodka $27
Seafood Linguine $39
Pappardelle Funghi $32
ENTRÉE
Chicken Parmigiana $42
12oz Prime Striploin $56
Branzino $39
ANTIPASTI
Mozzarella Caprese $26
Burrata & Prosciutto $29
Calamari Fritti $27
Polpette $25
Carpaccio di Manzo $28
Shrimp Fra Diavolo $36
SALAD
Cavolo $18
Caesar $17
Rucola $16
PIZZA
Diavola $24
Margherita $22
Salsiccia $26
Parma $25
Mushroom & Truffle $27
Pepperoni $23

Contact:

(905) 940-1555

Mon-Sun: 11:30am - 3pm| 5pm - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship:Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines

Contact Business

EAST SIDE MARIO'S STOUFFVILLE REVIEWS

East Side Mario is always my family favourite restaurant. This Stouffville location is clean & tidy. Nice vibe and atmosphere. Plenty parking in this plaza. Excellent customer service. The server Diane was very friendly and helpful. Food served fast & warm. Their signatures garlic home loaf, garden salad and Italian wedding soup were great as usual. Their chicken Parmesan with spaghetti was really delicious. They offer $3.99 all you can drink Purple lemonade, the color was very beautiful but it tasted pretty sweet, so we couldn’t be able to finish one glass. Overall experience was great. Can’t wait to visit again.

We got a three cheese ravioli and a chicken parmigiana with all you can eat bread and soup. The chicken was pretty dry and the ravioli Alfredo sauce was lacking in flavor. The tomato soup was a little too thick. Overall, it is a good deal as all pasta dishes come with all you can eat options. But do not have high expectations for the quality.

We enjoyed a great lunch here. The food was very good; however, the service was very slow. I recommend the salmon meal.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.ca.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

PASTAGGIO ITALIAN EATERY REVIEWS

A GEM IN STOUFFVILLE! A truly delicious menue with fair prices and good portions. Lucky to have such a beautiful family run business so close to home. The owners and staff make you feel right at home and treat you like family. Always something new to try with specials from time to time. Upstairs can accommodate around 100 people for private events and the building provides an elevator to reach the second floor it there are mobility issues with friends or family. I would defiantly recommend this establishment for anyone looking for some authentic Italian food. Bravo.

Small Italian eatery in main street Stouffville that specializes in authentic Italian food. They have lots of aps, entrees and desserts with countless vegetarian options. Ordered apps of tomato garlic cheese bread which was soft and easy to eat. Entrees consisted of veal parm and primavera which were both delicious and hearty. White wine is also delicious. Great place to go for Italian eatery.

Great service and very friendly. Food is decent and good price. Loved the grilled squids and they are tender. Parking: Street parking.

IL POSTINO REVIEWS

I’ve been here several times and have basically tried all the pasta dishes by now and each time they are all consistently good. Crust on the pizza has a good balance of crispiness and thickness. Recommend the lemon pasta and prosciutto pizza. You can ask for a spicy sauce to come with the pizza that adds a nice flavour to it as well. Service is pretty standard, sometimes there will be times where your waiter will fill your waters with the water jug at your table which is nice. Food comes out extremely quickly, even during peak dinner hours.

The atmosphere is overall good. Service is also good but I felt they are a bit understaffed and there is a sense of rush in my recent visit. As for the food, I like them overall but the seafood linguine dish has a bit too much olive oil and felt a bit too heavy. The bread was served with lots of oil on the plate. I rather to add the oil myself. It’s too much oil for my taste. The pizza and tiramisu are excellent though.

We enjoyed a nice gathering in the restaurant. The salads are very fresh. The Rigatoni Vodka is very tasty. The Burrata and Prosciutto are nice companions. We will come against in the future.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

EAST SIDE MARIO'S STOUFFVILLE Total Inspection Points: 120/120
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Current Evaluation: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Videos: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

PASTAGGIO ITALIAN EATERY Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Reviews Accuracy: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Special Features: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

IL POSTINO Total Inspection Points: 112/120
Current Evaluation: 8
Experience: 8
Reviews Study: 8
Business Hours: 9
Legitimate Ratings: 9
Table Reservations: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Pricing: 10
Videos: 10

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.