3 Best Italian Restaurants in Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON. All of our italian restaurants actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

5+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

EAST SIDE MARIO'S STOUFFVILLE

5769 Main Street,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 4R2 Directions

Since 1987

Specialities:

✓Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini ✓Double-Bacon Carbonara ✓Linguine Chicken Amatriciana ✓Cheese Cappelletti ✓Lasagna ✓Gigantic Three Cheese Ravioli ✓Spaghetti Primavera with Goat Cheese ✓Sausage and Peppers Penne ✓Jumbo Shrimp Alfredo ✓Seafood Linguine ✓Roasted Garlic Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken ✓Mario's Spaghetti and Meatballs ✓Build Your Own Pasta ✓Scallop Carbonara

"East Side Mario's Stouffville is a fine dining restaurant chain Italian restaurant that proudly serves the community with the best dining experience. Their team of staff use only high-quality ingredients for their dishes. The restaurant is the perfect place to dine in on special occasions like birthdays, anniversaries, business meetings, and more. They have a wide range of menus, are entrees, pasta, sandwiches, parmigiana, pizza, soups, salads, starters, and desserts at affordable prices. Place your order online and enjoy the Italian experience at home. East Side Mario's Stouffville offers gift cards in various price ranges. On Wednesdays, join them in their dining rooms and enjoy All-You-Can-Eat pasta with soup & salads. The restaurant also offers Wifi, takeout, delivery, patio, curbside pick-up, and bar. They provide Buy One, Take One Home Free on every Wednesday. Sign up on their website and receive a free starter on your next online order. They provide gift cards.

2026 Highlights: They are serious about two things food and famiglia bringing massive hand gestures, abundant dishes, and a gigantico love for family directly to the dining table."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #281195693

Menu:

Pasta
Creamy Garlic Steak Fettuccine $26.99
Crispy Chicken Bacon Rose $24.99
Shrimp & Salmon Spaghetti $26.49
Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini $24.79
Double-Bacon Carbonara $23.99
Linguine Chicken Amatriciana $23.89
Cheese Cappelletti $23.29
Gigantico Three Cheese Ravioli $24.99
Spaghetti Primavera With Goat Cheese $22.99
Homemade Meat Lasagna $24.29
Sausage & Peppers Penne $22.99
Shrimp Alfredo $24.89
Roasted Garlic Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken $23.79
Mario's Spaghetti & Meatballs $22.99
Build Your Own Pasta $21.99
Fettuccine Alfredo $19.99
Cheesy Baked Penne With Rosé $19.99
Spaghetti Bolognese $19.99
Pizza
Deluxe Pizza $16.99
Balsamic Pesto Pizza $16.99
Hawaiian Heat Pizza $16.99
The Ultimate Canadian Pizza $16.99
Four Meat Pizza $16.99
Pepperoni Calzone $17.99

Discount:

Get Free Appetizer Just by Signing Up

Contact:

(365) 521-2002

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

PASTAGGIO ITALIAN EATERY

6211 Main Street,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 4J3 Directions

Specialities:

✓Lasagna ✓Cappelletti ✓Gnocchi ✓Spaghetti with Meatballs ✓Spaghetti Aglio e Olio ✓Strozzapreti with Rapini and Sausage ✓Fettuccine Alfredo ✓Pasta alla Vodka ✓Penne Arrabbiata ✓Spaghetti con Gamberi e Calamari ✓Pasta with Meat Sauce ✓Pasta Primavera ✓Fusilli Salmone ✓Chicken Penne Pesto ✓Veal ✓Chicken Cutlet ✓Meatball ✓Italian Sausage ✓Ravioli ✓Pappardelle with Spicy Jumbo Shrimp

"Pastaggio Italian Eatery is an authentic Italian restaurant that provides the freshest and finest ingredients used to prepare their house specialties, including their Polo Parigina, Agnello alla Grilla, and unique pasta dishes, such as their Stozzapreti with Rapini and Sausage or Pasta alla Vodka. They strive to provide customers with the best quality food in a cozy environment. You will experience the flavourful food prepared by their professional staff. The restaurant also offers catering and hall rental services. Visit and dine with them to experience the best Italian cuisine in town. They offer dine-in, take out, catering, special events and upstairs hall rental. Their chefs use only the premium tomatoes and the best herbs and spices when preparing their sauces.

2026 Highlights: They are a family-run establishment that preserves Italian culinary authenticity by preparing house specialties like Pollo Parigina and unique Strozzapreti pasta using a lively exhibition kitchen."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Reader's Choice Best Italian Restaurant in 2009

Menu:

Pasta
Lasagna $26.00
Ravioli $28.00
Gnocchi $25.00
Spaghetti With Meatballs $25.00
Spaghetti Aglio E Olio $18.00
Strozzapreti With Rapini And Sausage $26.00
Fettuccine Alfredo $25.00
Pasta Alla Vodka $25.00
Penne Arrabbiata $20.00
Add Sausage $8.00
Spaghetti Con Gamberi E Calamari $27.00
Pasta With Meat Sauce $25.00
Pappardelle With Spicy Jumbo Shrimp $29.00
Pasta Primavera $22.00
Fusilli Salmone $25.00
Chicken Penne Pesto $26.00
Add Chicken Or Shrimp To Your Pasta $8.00
Entrees
Veal Parmigiana $32.00
Chicken Parmigiana $32.00
Pollo Parigina $37.00
Veal Chop $49.00
Steak $49.00
Add Peppercorn Sauce $5.00
Pork Chops $37.00
Agnello Alla Griglia $49.00
Salmone Alla Griglia $37.00
Appetizers
Frittura Di Calamari $22.00
Frittura Di Calamari With Spicy Blue Cheese Sauce $25.0

Contact:

(905) 642-5617

Thu: 4pm - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 9:30 pm
Sun-Wed: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

IL POSTINO

186 Main Street, Unionville,
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L3R 2G9 Directions

Since 2005

Specialities:

✓Mozzarella Caprese ✓Cavolo Salad ✓Arancini ✓Grilled Branzino ✓Spicy Prawn Linguine ✓Rigatoni Vodka ✓Spaghetti Cacio e Pepe ✓Fettuccine Limone ✓Tagliatelle Ragu ✓Orecchiette Sausage and Rapini ✓Seafood Linguine ✓Chicken Caesar ✓Margherita Pizza ✓Diavola Pizza ✓Pappardelle Funghi ✓Chicken Parmesan ✓Branzino ✓Mushroom and Truffle Pizza ✓Salsiccia Pizza ✓Parma Pizza ✓Steak Frites ✓Burrata Caprese ✓Calamari Fritti ✓Caesar Salad ✓Carpaccio

"Il Postino offers high-quality Italian fare, including house-made pasta. This restaurant is located 20 minutes from the downtown of Stouffville. The restaurant has a welcoming environment with a house-front patio. The secret success of this restaurant is outstanding service, exceptional service, and authentic food. Their team of staff use only good quality ingredients to make their delicious dishes. They have a daily special and an extensive wine list to enjoy. Il Postino's goal is to give authentic dishes to their customers. Their food is very flavorful, and the prices are reasonable. Guests can also enjoy their dining on a beautiful outdoor patio area. The restaurant has received the Consumer Choice Award.

2026 Highlights: They also provide dedicated gift cards for food lovers and private dining spaces to host special events."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pasta
Fettuccine Limone $28.00
Tagliatelle Ragu $29.00
Orecchiette Sausage & Rapini $29.00
Rigatoni Vodka $34.00
Seafood Linguine $39.00
Pappardelle Funghi $36.00
Entrata
Chicken Parmigiana $46.00
Mediterranean Sea Bass $52.00
Peppercorn Steak $64.00
Pizza
Diavola $25.00
Margherita $23.00
Salsiccia $26.00
Parma $26.00
Mushroom & Truffle $27.00
Pepperoni $24.00
Antipasti
Mozzarella Caprese $28.00
Burrata & Prosciutto $34.00
Calamari Fritti $32.00
Polpette $29.00
Carpaccio Di Manzo $30.00
Shrimp Fra Diavolo $39.00
Salad
Cavolo $19.00
Caesar $18.00
Rucola $17.00
Add Grilled Chicken Supreme $17.00
Add Grilled Atlantic Salmon $19.00

Contact:

(905) 940-1555

Mon-Sun: 11:30am - 3pm| 5pm - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.