3 Best Cakes in St. Catharines, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in St. Catharines, ON. All of our Cake Shops actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

THE FROSTED CUPCAKE

524 Lake Street,
St. Catharines, ON L2N 4H4 Directions

Since 2008

Specialty:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Vanilla Rainbow Chocolate Lemon Carrot Pineapple Coconut Marble Banana Apple Cinnamon. Strawberry Blueberry Raspberry Cherry Custard Cheesecake OCCASIONS: Birthdays Showers Weddings Gender Reveals Bachelorettes

The Frosted Cupcake provides custom cupcakes for your special occasions. Niagara’s first cupcake shop offers at least 20 tempting flavours daily. Their cupcakes are baked fresh from scratch daily in their nut-free facility using the finest ingredients. The Frosted Cupcake also makes delicious gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan cupcakes (by order) because everyone deserves a treat. Their team strives to provide valued customers with cakes that prove you can have an exceptionally gorgeous aesthetic without compromising flavour. Their cakes are free from chemical additives, preservatives, and mixes. Their team provides cupcakes, candy, cake pops, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and stuffed chocolate chip cookie sandwiches. Catering services are available for all occasions, such as birthdays, weddings, showers, corporate events, bachelor parties, etc.

2025 Update: The Frosted Cupcake has tested out dozens of recipes to come up with the perfect taste for each flavour. All of their cupcakes and cakes are baked fresh in their nut-free facility from the finest ingredients for your wedding day.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

CAKE SIZES & PRICING
6 inch serves 10 $75
8 inch serves 20 $100
10 inch serves 30 $150
12 inch serves 40 $200
2 tier serves 30 to 36 $250
3 tier serves 70 to 80 $525
4 tier serves 90+ $800
Regular Cupcakes
Single $3.50
Half dozen $20.00
Dozen $39.00
Mini Cupcakes
Single $2.25

Contact:

(905) 934-0003

Tue-Wed & Sat: 10am - 6pm
Thu & Fri: 10am - 8pm
Sat: 10am - 6pm
Sun: 10am - 4pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SUBS PLUS

211 Scott Street,
St. Catharines, ON L2N 1H5 Directions

Since 1985

Specialty:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Chocolate White and Marble Cakes Carrot Red Velvet Black Forest Vegan Raspberry Lemon and Keylime Custard whip Cream Key Lime Butter Cream Chocolate Whip Cherry Chocolate Butter Cream Strawberry Fudge Cupcakes OCCASIONS: Wedding Birthday Anniversary and Bridal Shower

Subs Plus has been serving Niagara’s favorite submarine sandwiches and custom cakes for over 39 years. Everything is made on-site and freshly baked every day. They are the winners of numerous local consumer choice awards and are committed to making tasty treats from scratch using premium ingredients. They also offer cookies, treats, cupcakes, signature cakes, and subs. Subs Plus never use chemicals or mixes in their cakes, ensuring only the finest organic ingredients are used. Their team uses only the highest quality ingredients to make their cupcakes, adding the finishing touch of deliciously smooth buttercream or cream cheese frosting. They specialize in celebration cakes for all occasions and offer a variety of dessert items, including gluten-free options.

2025 Update: Subs Plus also offers Subs, Baked Goods, and parties. Wendy and Robert Dumas are the owners of this shop, who make everything on site, fresh baked every day.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #728280

Price:

Delight Cakes
From $38.95
To $184.95
Classic Cake
From $34.95
To $174.95
Carrot & red velvet
From $38.95
To $92.95
Christmas dessert trays:
From $36.95
To $74.95
Vegan cakes
From $38.95
To $72.95
Bento cake box w/ cupcakes $49.95
Gluten-free cakes
From $42.95
To $79.95
Black forest cake
From $38.95
To $184.95
Cupcakes$34.99
Chocolate Fudge Sprinkle Cake $27.99
White Butter Cream Sprinkle Cake $27.99
White Custard Whip Cream Sprinkle Cake $27.99
Valentine Heart Shape Cake "8" $44.95
Mini Cheese Cakes $2.49
Cake Slice $3.89

Contact:

(905) 646-0111 (905) 641-4404

Mon-Sat: 11am - 7pm
Sun:11am - 4pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

THE KETO CRUMB.

30 Church Street,
St. Catharines, ON L2R 3B6 Directions

Since 2020

Specialty:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Cheesecake Chocolates Vanilla Maple Dream Chocolate Mousse Strawberry Shortcake Carrot Cake Black Forest Turtles Lemon Chocolate Hazelnut Mixed Berry Cookies & Cream Mint Oreo Pistachio OCCASIONS: Birthday Wedding Anniversary

The Keto Crumb team specializes in handcrafted, premium celebration cakes for any occasion. Angela and Alex are the owners of the cake shop. They use only the finest ingredients to handcraft their cakes, cupcakes, and sweet treats. They aim to deliver high-quality, delicious cakes every time. They are made with high-quality, low-carb ingredients. Each treat is designed to delight your taste buds while staying guilt-free and keto-friendly. They are committed to providing the best bakery items at a reasonable price. Their skilled bakers are passionate about creating the most delicious bakery items. The Keto Crumb takes pride in using carefully chosen fine ingredients from local farmers. All their cake toppers are made with the freshest ingredients without compromising quality or taste.

2025 Update: Their selection of keto-friendly desserts is crafted to satisfy your sweet tooth without compromising your dietary goals.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #300988698

Price:

CUSTOM CAKES FOR ANY OCCASION
"6" Cake or Cheesecake $49.00
"10" Cake or Cheesecake $69.00
Lactose or Dairy Free $10.00
SAVOURY TREATS
Bagel Bomb $5.95
Premium Bagel Bomb $6.95
Pizza Slice $6.50
Mini Bagels $4.00
Crackers $6.50
BARS
Each $5.95
GLUTEN-FREE
Cupcake $6.25
Premium Cookie $4.25
Danish $5.75
SUGAR-FREE PARFAITS
Lace Cookie $4.50
Muffin $5.00
VEGAN
Cake Slices $6.25
"6” Pie $17.50
Scone $5.75
Cheesecake Slices $6.95
Tarts $5.95
Cinnamon Roll $6.00

Contact:

(289) 990-7000

Mon-Fri: 10am - 5pm
Sat: 9am - 5pm
Sun: 11am - 4pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.