3 Best Cakes in Whitby, ON

I ordered a communion and confirmation Incorporated cake and sugar cookies from Piccadilly bakery. Elizabeth, the owner is amazing. She does every detail so perfectly and she does it with so much love and passion as if it’s for her own family. The cake and the cookies were delicious and exactly the way we wanted it. I am so impressed and touched by the service I received. All of the guest were so impressed with the detailed work on the cake and the sugar cookies and of course it tasted amazing. The best sugar cookies I have ever eaten. Thank you so much Elizabeth for going above and beyond to make the cake and the sugar cookies absolutely perfect.

If I could give them 6 stars, I would! The pastry chefs are incredibly skilled and professional, and the pastries are absolutely delicious—some of the best in town. From cakes to desserts to macarons, everything is crafted with excellence. We need more pastry shops like this, where real chefs create the best of the best. Highly recommended—I can’t wait to go back! Keep up the amazing work.

Ordered a cake and a dozen vegan cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday. I’m usually a “let the experts do their thing” when trying a new place which can sometimes be hit or miss. This was a huge hit!! Lemon cake with a light honey buttercream frosting. I don’t know cake specifics but every guest loved the cake and I almost kept it all for myself it was so delicious!!!! Found my new go-to bakery!

Susi is amazing! I tell everyone I have a fantastic cake lady! This is my third order so far and we continue to be impressed. She will customize the cake however you like with whatever design/theme you choose. Or just let her be creative and see what she comes up with! You will not be disappointed! Also tastes fantastic. Very light/fluffy/moist layered chocolate & vanilla cake (can be customized for only chocolate or only vanilla). Icing is fantastic. She is also super nice and can often accommodate rush orders with only a few days notice. My next order may very well be just because! Not for any special occasion. Maybe I'll have her write 'Erica's cake! Enjoy!'

I got a gorgeous cake built by Susi for my son's first birthday and he dummied about half of it on his own. The guests loved it, my son loved it, but most important my wife loved it. Thanks again Susi, you're a delight!

I loved my cake! it was so yummy and beautiful! i had so many people telling me how much they loved it. Susi was so lovely as well! Thank you so much if any friends need a cake will definetly be referring!