3 Best Insurance Brokers in Peterborough, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Insurance Agency in Peterborough, ON. All of our insurance brokers actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

8+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

DARLING INSURANCE

193 Aylmer Street North, P.O. Box 385,
Peterborough, ON K9J 6Z3

Since 1928

Specialty:

✓Personal Insurance ✓Business Insurance ✓Agriculture Insurance ✓Lions Club Insurance ✓Life Insurance and Financial Services ✓RV Trailer Insurance ✓Travel Insurance ✓CAA Membership ✓House/Tenants/Condominium ✓Cottage/Boats ✓Secondary Home/Rental ✓Auto/Motorcycle/ATV/Snowmobile ✓Personal Umbrella Liability ✓High-Value Homes ✓Builders Risk/Vacant Homes ✓Home-Based Business ✓Contractors/Retail/Office ✓Business Interruption ✓Directors and Officers ✓Professional Liability/Errors and Omissions ✓Cyber ✓Student Rentals ✓Manufacturing ✓Business Auto/Truck ✓Marine ✓Special Events/Sports and Entertainment ✓Auto Dealers Program ✓Condo Corporations ✓Vacant

"Darling Insurance has been a trusted insurer for all home, vehicle, agricultural and business needs. Their offices are designed to offer customers local, convenient and dependable claims service. They are your best choice for home, car, truck, ATV, RV, cottage, farm and business insurance. Their specialized team of brokers is dedicated to finding you appropriate and affordable insurance coverage that fits you best. Darling Insurance offers a wide range of protection for your modern farm, including coverage for machinery, buildings, produce, livestock, loss of income, farm liability, limited pollution liability and legal liability. You can get free, no-obligation instant online insurance quotes. The firm also has branches in Lakefield and Omemee. Darling Insurance combines quality service with today’s technology to deliver the best insurance possible to their clients.

2026 Highlights: Darling Insurance provides 24/7 assistance for claims, including an after-hours emergency services."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #1035498

Contact:

(705) 742-4245 (800) 387-1627

Mon-Fri: 8:30am - 4:30pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

BILLYARD INSURANCE GROUP PETERBOROUGH

1600 Lansdowne Street West, Unit 2,
Peterborough, ON K9J 7C7 Directions

Since 2021

Specialty:

✓Car ✓RV/motorhome ✓Classic Car ✓Life Insurance ✓Critical Illness ✓Personal Health ✓Pet ✓Group Benefits ✓Travel ✓Boat ✓Motorcycle ✓Home ✓Condo ✓Tenants ✓Rental Property ✓Cottage ✓Commercial Liability ✓Professional Liability ✓Small Business ✓Commercial Property and Auto ✓Insurance ✓Frequent Traveler ✓Students and Seniors Insurances

"Billyard Insurance Group Peterborough offers Home, Auto, Life, Travel, and Business Insurance through various trusted insurance partners to clients. Steve Nicholls is the managing partner of the firm. They have over 800 brokers to find you the best price and coverage while providing outstanding and personal customer service. They aim to ensure you are provided with coverages and pricing that perfectly fits your needs. They offer a wide variety of products, so they can provide suitable options through their approachable and educated insurance brokers. They understand that looking for the best insurance products can be a daunting task at Billyard Insurance; they will make this a smooth and easy process for you. They value your time and will ensure you receive timely and efficient service that will exceed your expectations.

2026 Highlights: BIG Peterborough provides personalized insurance solutions through 30+ trusted providers, with online quotes in under 3 minutes and 24/7 digital client access."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Discount:

Save $300 on insurance with BIG for Peterborough drivers

Contact:

(705) 201-7826 (833) 996-7826

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

MCDOUGALL INSURANCE & FINANCIAL PETERBOROUGH

261 George Street North,
Peterborough, ON K9J 3G9 Directions

Since 1946

Specialty:

✓Auto Insurance ✓Car Insurance ✓Classic Car Insurance ✓Experienced Drivers Insurance ✓High Risk Car Insurance ✓Young Drivers Insurance ✓Home Insurance ✓Condo Insurance ✓Cottage Insurance ✓Airbnb Insurance ✓Renters Insurance ✓Builder’s Risk Insurance ✓Recreational Insurance ✓ATV Insurance ✓Boat Insurance ✓Motorcycle Insurance ✓Snowmobile Insurance ✓RV and Travel Trailer Insurance ✓Life Insurance ✓Life Insurance Overview ✓Individual Life Insurance ✓Individual Health Benefits ✓Travel Insurance ✓Critical Illness Insurance ✓Disability Insurance ✓Auto Garage Insurance ✓Beauticians’ Insurance ✓Certificate of Insurance and Commercial Auto Insurance

"McDougall Insurance & Financial Peterborough has over 60 years of experience in the field, and their team covers your home and auto insurance, any business or commercial insurance needs, and your life insurance needs, providing all of this coverage under one roof. Their team combines their knowledge and relationships with McDougall Insurance's size and market access to ensure you find an affordable policy with the highest level of service. Their Peterborough insurance brokers help you protect your biggest investment. Their knowledgeable staff will guide you through the condo insurance quote process, advising you on what coverages you actually need. McDougall Insurance also has branches in Picton, Prescott, Prince Edward County, Sudbury, Sunderland, Trenton, Tweed, Wellington, Winchester and more. You can contact them to get a free quote. They represent over 50 insurance companies, giving them the ability to offer you an optimal selection and competitive rates.

2026 Highlights: McDougall Insurance offers 24/7 digital client services."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #859678575

Discount:

Save up to 15% when home and auto insurance is carried through the same insurer

Contact:

(705) 742-8864 (800) 958-2270

Mon-Fri: 8:30am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.