3 Best Pizza Places in Hamilton, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Hamilton, ON. All of our Pizza Restaurants actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

CHICAGO STYLE PIZZA

534 Upper Sherman Avenue,
Hamilton, ON L8V 3M1 Directions

Since 1946

Specialities:

✓Medium Regular Crust Pizza ✓Large Regular Crust Pizza ✓Medium Thick Crust Pizza ✓Large Thick Crust Pizza ✓Personal Stuffed Pizza ✓Small Stuffed Pizza ✓Large Stuffed Pizza ✓Medium Thin Crust Pizza ✓Large Thin Crust Pizza ✓Small Garden Salad ✓Large Garden Salad ✓Small Caesar Salad ✓Large Caesar Salad ✓Fried Ravioli ✓Battered Mushrooms ✓Appy Platter ✓Bruschetta ✓Garlic Bread ✓Garlic Bread With Cheese ✓Cheesecake ✓Chocolate Marble Cheesecake ✓Cherry Cheesecake ✓Black Forest Cheesecake ✓Tiramisu ✓Lemon Tiramisu

"Chicago Style Pizza proudly serves a variety of pizzas made with the help of the most delicate ingredients. Some iconic pizzas are thick, thin, stuffed, white and regular. The base of all pizza is exceptional dough. This traditional pizza restaurant offers a unique Pizza Pie made in a deep dish pan and loaded with cheese and pizza sauce. Enjoy the thick-crust pizza with a wide variety of toppings, such as well-dressed and more. Dine-in and takeaway options are available. They take pride in their work, products, and services. The restaurant offers vegan menus. High chairs are available for kids. Chicago Style Pizza provides delivery and catering services for their customers' events. The restaurant offers a vegetarian menu and has a television for entertainment. They accept debit cards for their customers' bills.

2026 Highlights: Chicago Style Pizza has a wheelchair-accessible restroom."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #280593005

Menu:

PIZZA:
Medium Regular Crust Pizza $23.75
Large Regular Crust Pizza $28.75
Medium Thick Crust Pizza $26.00
Large Thick Crust Pizza $32.75
Personal Stuffed Pizza $19.00
Small Stuffed Pizza $31.50
Large Stuffed Pizza $47.00
Medium Thin Crust Pizza $21.50
Large Thin Crust Pizza $28.75
APPETIZERS:
Small Garden Salad $6.75
Large Garden Salad $9.50
Small Caesar Salad $10.00
Large Caesar Salad $14.75
Fried Ravioli $7.75
Battered Mushrooms $11.50
Appy Platter $19.25
Bruschetta $11.25
Garlic Bread $6.25
Garlic Bread With Cheese $12.00
DESSERT:
Cheesecake $7.50
Chocolate Marble Cheesecake $7.50
Cherry Cheesecake $7.50
Black Forest Cheesecake $7.50
Tiramisu $8.50
Lemon Tiramisu $9.25

Contact:

(905) 575-8800

Mon: Closed
Tue-Thu: 4:30pm - 9:30pm
Fri: 4:30pm - 10:30pm
Sat: 4pm - 10:30pm
Sun: 4pm - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

6+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

BOSTON PIZZA

1565 Upper James Street,
Hamilton, ON L9B 1K2 Directions

Since 1964

Specialities:

✓Shareables ✓Pasta ✓Pizza ✓Sandwiches and Burgers ✓Bowls and Salads ✓Mains ✓Desserts ✓Kids Menu ✓Glutenwise ✓Spinach and Artichoke Dip ✓The Triple Play ✓Chicken Fingers ✓Create Your Own Pizza ✓Cactus Cut Potatoes ✓Spicy Perogy ✓Chicken Parmesan ✓Classic Nachos (starter size)

"Boston Pizza has served communities from coast to coast for 60 years, since opening its first restaurant in Edmonton, Alberta, in 1964. The restaurant is famous for its signature hand-pressed pizza dough and gourmet pizzas. This casual and friendly chain pizza restaurant's extensive menu satisfies every appetite with mouth-watering pasta dishes and various salads, entrées and desserts. Boston Pizza has been serving more locations and guests annually than any other casual dining concept in the country. The restaurant has more than 380 locations. The restaurant provides gift cards. Boston Pizza has television and free Wi-Fi connectivity to create a good vibe. The restaurant provides take-out and delivery options, and it offers outdoor seating to have a memorable dining experience. They provide vegetarian and kids' options in their extensive menu and accept debit cards to make transactions easy.

2026 Highlights: Boston Pizza has a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking lot, and restroom accessibility."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Spinach & Artichoke Dip $17.99
The Triple Play $26.69
Chicken Fingers $10.89
Create Your Own Pizza $12.89
Cactus Cut Potatoes $15.29
Spicy Perogy $16.39
Chicken Parmesan $27
Classic Nachos (Starter Size) $19.39

Contact:

(905) 574-0333

Mon-Thu & Sun: 11am - 12am
Fri & Sat: 11am - 1am

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

SHORTY'S PIZZA

1099 Cannon Street East,
Hamilton, ON L8L 2J6 Directions

Specialities:

✓Pizza Slices ✓NY Cheese ✓Margherita ✓Pepperoni ✓White ✓Spicy Sausage ✓Veggie Deluxe ✓Bacon and Mushroom ✓Elote ✓Hawaiian ✓Spicy Deluxe ✓Nodini ✓Salad ✓Dips ✓Banana Pudding

"Shorty's Pizza uses only fresh-sourced ingredients for its pizzas. Pizzas are made crispy in the crust and chewy in the middle. The restaurant is a warm and cozy environment. Their team of staff is very friendly and supports all the needs of the customers. They also have gluten-free dough for making Pizza. Dine-in and takeaway options are also available. They pride themselves on providing mouthwatering menus for their customers. You and your guests will enjoy yourselves significantly in this pizzeria. They provide vegan-friendly menus. Outdoor seating and vegetarian dishes are available in this restaurant. Shorty's Pizza has television for its customers to have an entertaining dining experience and offers a validated parking facility for their customers' convenience.

2026 Highlights: Shorty's Pizza has a wheelchair-accessible entrance."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #1000695044

Menu:

SLICES:
Pizza Slices $9.95
Ny Cheese 14 Inch $18.50
Ny Cheese 18 Inch $26
Margherita 14 Inch $21
Margherita 18 Inch $28.50
Pepperoni 14 Inch $22.50
Pepperoni 18 Inch $31
White 14 Inch $22.50
White 18 Inch $31
Spicy Sausage 14 Inch $23.50
Spicy Sausage 18 Inch $32
Veggie Deluxe 14 Inch $21.50
Veggie Deluxe 18 Inch $29.50
Bacon & Mushroom 14 Inch $23.50
Bacon & Mushroom 18 Inch $32
Elote 14 Inch $23
Elote 18 Inch $31.50
Hawaiian 14 Inch $22
Hawaiian 18 Inch $30.50
Spicy Deluxe 14 Inch $23.50
Spicy Deluxe 18 Inch $32
Nodini 6 For $5.75
Nodini 12 For $8.75
Salad $14
Dips $2.50 Each
Banana Pudding $9

Contact:

(905) 312-9293

Mon-Sun: 11:30am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.