ThreeBestRated.ca
BEST RATED THUNDER BAY, ON CAKES FR

3 Best Cakes in Thunder Bay, ON

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in Thunder Bay, ON. All of our Cake Shops actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and price - all to ensure overall excellence. You deserve only the best!

Milk & Water Baking Co. - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Menu Image
Milk & Water Baking Co. - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Restaurant Exterior Image
Milk & Water Baking Co. - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Dish Image
Thunder Bay cake Milk & Water Baking Co. video
3+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

MILK & WATER BAKING CO.

(4.9 Score)
379 Main Street, Unit C1A,
Thunder Bay, ON P7B 5L6 Directions

Since 2017

Specialities:

✓CAKE FLAVORS: Vanilla ✓Cookies N’ Cream ✓Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ✓Chocolate ✓Confetti Cookie Dough ✓After Eight ✓Lemon ✓Raspberry Shortbread ✓Birthday Cake ✓Coconut ✓Nanaimo Bar ✓Chocolate Salted Caramel ✓Persian and Butter Tart ✓Vegan Cupcakes ✓Gluten-Friendly CupcakesOCCASIONS: Birthday ✓Wedding ✓Anniversary ✓Engagement ✓Parties

"Milk & Water Baking Co. created a unique design for each occasion. Ellen Bright is the owner of the cake shop. They carefully make cakes to order, using the best ingredients and carefully crafting each one. They take pride in providing high-quality and delicious cakes at an affordable price. Each cake is prepared from scratch in tiny batches by highly creative bakers using the freshest ingredients at their on-site bakery. All their cakes are prepared with the freshest and highest-quality ingredients to ensure everything is fresh and delicious. Milk & Water Baking Co. makes 6-12 different flavours of cupcakes daily for walk-ins.

2026 Highlights: They have a base recipe for their cakes, and their cupcakes are both peanut. and tree nut-free. They have hundreds of fresh-baked cupcakes and a selection of display cakes for walk-in purchase."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

CAKES:
Cutie Cake $22.00
6-Inch Heart Cake $40.00
6-Inch Cake $45.00
8-Inch Cake $50.00
9-Inch Heart Cake $50.00
9-Inch Cake $55.00
10-Inch Cake $65.00
12-Inch Cake $85.00
COOKIES:
1 Cookie $2.25
12 Cookies $18.00
1 Iced Cookie $2.75
12 Iced Cookies $30.00
BARS AND BROWNIES:
1 Bar $4.00
6 Bars $20.00
12 Bars $35.00
MINI CHEESECAKES:
1 Cheesecake $3.50
6 Cheesecakes $18.00
12 Cheesecakes $32.00
Gluten-Friendly Cupcakes:
1 Cupcake $4.75
6 Cupcakes $25.00
12 Cupcakes $45.00

Discount:

Buy 12 Cupcakes, Get the 13th Free with the Baker's Dozen Card

Contact:

(807) 767-8867

Mon: Closed
Tue-Fri: 11am - 6pm
Sat & Sun: 11am - 4pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Carol's Cakes - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Service Highlights
Carol's Cakes - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Menu Image
Carol's Cakes - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Dish Image
Thunder Bay cake Carol's Cakes video
10+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

CAROL'S CAKES

(4.9 Score)
110 Waterloo Street South,
Thunder Bay, ON P7E 2C3 Directions

Since 1990

Specialities:

✓CAKE FLAVORS: Red Velvet ✓Tarts ✓Cookies and Shortbread ✓Chocolate ✓Classic Cheese ✓Coconut ✓Mousse ✓Cupcakes ✓Mango Cheese ✓French Macarons ✓Corporate ✓Carrot ✓Biscotti ✓Loaves ✓Banana ✓Lemon ✓Spice ✓Traditional Birthday Flowers ✓Traditional Confetti and Streamers ✓Flower and Chocolate Drip Theme ✓Strawberry Shortcake ✓Black Forest Cake ✓Wildflower Cake ✓Cherry Blossom Cake ✓Vintage Cake ✓Watercolor Cake ✓Candy Bar Torte ✓Baby Blocks ✓OCCASIONS: Wedding ✓Engagement ✓Events ✓Birthday ✓Anniversary ✓Corporate Events

"Carol's Cakes is a custom cake shop that has been offering high-quality, well-priced, delicious products for over 35 years. Their mission is to consistently serve delicious, affordable, and beautiful cake products in celebration of life. Each cake they make is unique and reflects the personality of the customer. Carol's Cakes also makes cakes without nuts. They're experts in making tasty cakes, muffins, and cupcakes. Carol's Cakes also caters for weddings, graduations, birthdays, baptisms, and communions. All their cakes are prepared with the freshest and highest-quality ingredients to ensure everything is fresh and delicious. They offer a variety of custom and standard designs and sizes for every type of celebration.

2026 Highlights: They are 100% nut-free and provide a variety of gluten-free options, along with a selection of grab-and-go treats for everyone."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #2038538

Menu:

Carol's Classics:
Sally & Mary Ann's $8.00
Carrot Cake $40.00
Mango & Toasted Coconut Cake $45.00
Cream Pies $15.00
COLLECTIONS:
Cake, Build-Your-Own $25.00
Cupcakes (6) $15.00
Cupcake-Cake, Build-Your-Own $35.00
AT A GLANCE:
Cake, Build-Your-Own $25.00

Contact:

(807) 577-0321

Mon: 10am - 3pm
Tue-Fri: 11am - 6pm
Sat & Sun: 10am - 3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Nucci's Bake A Deli - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Menu Image
Nucci's Bake A Deli - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Restaurant Exterior Image
Nucci's Bake A Deli - Thunder Bay, ON Cakes - Dish Image
9+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

NUCCI'S BAKE A DELI

(4.8 Score)
801 Red River Road,
Thunder Bay, ON P7B 1J9 Directions

Since 1983

Specialities:

✓CAKE FLAVORS: Traditional Birthday Cakes ✓Fruit-filled Cakes ✓Buttercream Cakes ✓Lemon Raspberry Cakes ✓Black Forest Cakes ✓Carrot Cakes ✓Vienna Sacher Cake ✓Sally-andrea Cake (Peanut Butter Cup) ✓Persian Sallyanne Cake ✓Red Velvet Cakes ✓Tiramisu Cakes ✓Italian Torte Cakes ✓New York Style Cheesecake ✓Original Persian Cakes ✓OCCASIONS: Birthday ✓Wedding ✓Anniversary ✓Engagement ✓Parties

“Nucci's Bake A Deli has provided delicious bread, Italian pastries, Pastries, Sallyannes, cookies, and cakes for over 42 years. Nucci’s has become a must-visit destination known for their extensive selection of deli meats, specialty cheeses, imported groceries, and deli sandwiches. The team is committed to providing the community with exceptional products and unique cake designs. They use the finest and freshest ingredients to ensure an extraordinary cake every time, specializing in crafting delicious cakes for all types of events. Try their delicious Triple Chocolate, Tiramisu, Red Velvet, and Persian Cake. Nucci's Bake A Deli also offers catering services for all special events. You can also customize cakes according to your specific requirements. Nucci's Bake A Deli provides Wheelchair-accessible facilities, and they offer a Takeaway and Delivery option also available. They provide quality services to guests.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License # 941298507

Menu:

CAKE:
9 Inch Round $28.99
11 Inch Round $34.99
Half Slab $48.99
Full Slab $91.99
XL Slab $125.99
LEMON RASPBERRY CAKES:
9 Inch Round (Up To 10 People) $33.99
11 Inch Round (11 - 15 People) $41.99
Half Slab (16 - 30 People) $58.99
Full Slab (31 - 60 People) $112.99
XL Slab (61 - 100 People) $155.99
PERSIAN SALLYANNE CAKE:
9 Inch Round (Up To 10 People) $33.99
11 Inch Round (11 - 15 People) $41.99
CARROT CAKES:
Cupcake (1 Cupcake) $3.49
9 Inch Round (Up To 10 People) $41.99
11 Inch Round (11 - 15 People) $52.99
Half Slab (16 - 30 People) $73.99
Full Slab (31 - 60 People) $136.99
TIRAMISU CAKES:
6 Inch Round (Up To 8 People) $23.99
8 Inch Round (Up To 10 People) $34.99
Half Slab (16 - 30 People) $89.99
Full Slab (31 - 60 People) $167.99

Contact:

(807) 767-4501

Mon-Fri: 9am - 7pm
Sat & Sun: 9am - 6pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship:Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines

Contact Business

MILK & WATER BAKING CO. REVIEWS

I ordered cupcakes to celebrate my daughter’s 23rd. I ordered from Toronto ( via skip the dishes bc no delivery available ) and the gang ( athletes at OWG- my daughter is a coach) who enjoyed them reported that they were fabulous ! They were really beautiful and obvious effort and creativity went into making them. I asked for a pastel floral theme with some white chocolate on chocolate cupcakes ! Perfection! Thank you Milk and Water for helping make my daughters 23rd very special .

I love to try local companies, instead of buying from grocery stores. We had an anniversary of a coworker at work and I was asked to get something for everyone. After seeing some pictures on Instagram I decided to try Milk & Water. Can we talk about first how esthetically pleasing not only the cupcakes look but the boxes, beautiful. The cupcakes were amazing everyone loved them. 10/10 recommend and will be back!.

I recently used Milk & Water for an event. The service was extremely easy to use, from quote to ordering, flavour choice and pick-up, we had no issues. The cupcakes were amazing and everyone at the event enjoyed them! After the fact I needed a receipt and the staff were quick to respond, troubleshoot and find me the receipt that I needed. Thanks for the great cupcakes!.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.ca.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

CAROL'S CAKES REVIEWS

Carol’s Cakes accommodated a pretty unique request for a party with a two-in-one theme for us! The final product was absolutely unreal and tasted as great as it looked! The price for the product was extremely fair and they were so wonderful to work with. Everyone was blown away - thank you!.

If I could just suggest that your website give a serving suggestion for your cakes. I bought a 1/2 slab which was way too big for our group but without some guidance it was hard to choose. The cake itself was wonderful as usual.

My MIL placed an order the day before my son's birthday and the cake was still ready on time. It was SO fluffy and light, and not too sweet.

NUCCI'S BAKE A DELI REVIEWS

We were passing through Thunder Bay and asked where to find the Persian donuts that Thunder Bay is famous for. The motel clerk directed us to Nucci's. At Nucci's, the Persian donuts are baked daily by The Persian Man and delivered to Nucci's. Nucci's had 3 flavours of frosting available: the original raspberry, chocolate, and blueberry. The cashier recommended we get a dozen packaged in plastic, with the tub of frosting provided separately, as those would best withstand the rigours of travel. Back in our hotel room, we sampled the donuts. Delicious! The pastry is the typical yeast raised donut, and the frosting is light and not too sweet, with a delicate raspberry flavour. There were other pastries and savouries available, but we had eyes only for the Persian donuts. Service was really friendly and helpful.

I have been going weekly to the Red River location for a couple years. I have really noticed that the staff have always been beyond friendly and a pleasure to deal with. Big thumbs up to the staff (over many years now), and we love all their in-house made items.

It was my birthday cake which was ordered by my friends from States. It was delivered on time, presentation was awesome and overall the cake was tasty. Thank you so much for such a best birthday cake.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

MILK & WATER BAKING CO. Total Inspection Points: 118/120
Experience: 8
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Current Evaluation: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Reviews Accuracy: 10
Variety of Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

CAROL'S CAKES Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Complete Info: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Business Hours: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Reviews Accuracy: 10
Variety of Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

NUCCI'S BAKE A DELI Total Inspection Points: 114/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Exact Services: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Variety of Menu: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Current Evaluation: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Online Order: 10

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.